Gain a competitive edge on Amazon with effective strategies for winning the Buy Box and Amazon's Choice - two crucial factors for driving higher sales.
Jens Vittrup
Are you selling on Amazon, or considering getting started? Then you have probably come across terms like “Buy Box” and “Amazon’s Choice” – but what do they really mean, and why are they so important? Today, we take a closer look at these crucial elements on the Amazon platform that can be the difference between average and exceptional sales results.
The Amazon marketplace is highly competitive, with millions of products vying for customer attention. To stand out in this environment, it is essential to understand and secure two of the platform’s most valuable positions: the Buy Box and the Amazon’s Choice badge.
Let’s start by exploring exactly what these terms mean, how they are awarded, and – most importantly – how you can optimise your product listings to win them. Whether you are a new seller or an experienced Amazon entrepreneur, these insights can transform your presence on the platform.
The Amazon Buy Box is the small box on the right-hand side of a product page where customers can click “Add to Basket” or “Buy Now”. It may seem simple, but this small box represents the most valuable position on Amazon. When a customer lands on a product page and decides to purchase, it’s the seller who holds the Buy Box who gets the order.
However, what many new sellers don’t realise is that, although several sellers can offer the same product, only one can “win” the Buy Box at any given time. This makes the Buy Box one of the most competitive aspects of selling on Amazon.
In fact, more than 80% of all sales on Amazon go through the Buy Box. Think about it: if your product is not in the Buy Box, you lose access to 4 out of 5 potential customers. That’s why consistently winning or losing the Buy Box can dramatically affect your ability to sell.
For new Amazon sellers, winning the Buy Box can be challenging, as Amazon favours established sellers with a solid track record. But it’s not impossible – especially if you understand the factors that influence the Buy Box algorithm.
Amazon’s algorithm for determining who wins the Buy Box is complex and considers many factors. Although Amazon doesn’t publish the exact formula, experienced sellers have identified several key factors that clearly impact your chances:
The Buy Box algorithm also rotates between eligible sellers based on their performance. This means that even if you don’t always have the Buy Box, you can still win it periodically if you meet Amazon’s requirements. This rotation system also provides Amazon with valuable data about which sellers deliver the best customer experience.
To qualify for the Buy Box, you must first ensure your Amazon Seller Central account is in good standing and your performance exceeds Amazon’s minimum requirements. This includes factors such as order fulfilment rate, shipping times, and customer feedback.
Amazon-related performance metrics play a crucial role in your chances of winning the Buy Box. Here are some of the most important factors that influence it:
For new sellers, building these metrics from scratch can be a challenge, but with professional guidance from Amazon consultants, you can accelerate the process and avoid common pitfalls that could harm your performance.
As a new seller on Amazon, competing for the Buy Box can feel overwhelming, especially against established sellers. However, with the right strategy, you can significantly improve your chances. Here are some effective approaches:
Begin by focusing on your account health and performance metrics. Amazon requires a professional seller account and a solid performance history before you even qualify for the Buy Box. Make sure to keep your cancellation rates, shipping times, and customer service at an excellent level.
Pricing strategy is another critical element. While it may be tempting to drastically lower prices to win the Buy Box, this isn’t always the best approach. Amazon doesn’t just look at the lowest price, but the overall value including shipping. Find a balance where you remain competitive without undermining your profitability.
Consider using Amazon FBA (Fulfilment by Amazon) as a new seller. FBA products typically have a higher chance of winning the Buy Box, as Amazon handles shipping, customer service, and returns, ensuring a high standard of customer experience. This can give you a considerable advantage, especially in the early stages of your Amazon journey.
Price competition is one of the most dynamic factors affecting the Buy Box. Here are some nuances you should be aware of:
An effective pricing strategy involves balancing competitiveness with profitability. Excessive price cuts can lead to a vicious cycle of price wars, ultimately harming all sellers. Instead, focus on providing value through reliable service, fast delivery, and product quality that justifies a healthy price point.
Regularly monitoring your competitors’ prices and Buy Box status is also crucial. By understanding how the market moves, you can make informed decisions about when to adjust your prices and when to hold firm to maximise your profitability.
Amazon’s Choice is a black badge displayed on selected products in Amazon’s search results. This badge represents Amazon’s recommendation for a specific product within a given search category. When Amazon awards this badge to your product, it signals to customers that your offer is a reliable, well-priced, high-quality choice.
The badge was originally introduced to help customers using Alexa for voice shopping identify the best products. Today, however, it holds much broader significance across the entire Amazon platform. It dramatically increases your product’s visibility in search results and can lead to significantly higher click-through rates.
For sellers, the Amazon’s Choice badge can potentially mean a massive boost in sales, as many customers see it as a guarantee of quality and value. It creates instant trust, especially among shoppers who do not want to spend time doing extensive research before a purchase.
But what does Amazon’s Choice actually mean for consumers? According to Amazon, the badge indicates that the product is “highly rated, well-priced, immediately available, and can be shipped right away.” This gives customers confidence in their buying decision.
Unlike the Buy Box, which has a relatively well-defined algorithm, the criteria for Amazon’s Choice are less transparent. Amazon has not published a complete list of factors that determine which products receive the badge. However, analysis and experience from successful sellers have revealed some key elements:
It is worth noting that the Amazon’s Choice badge is awarded per search term, not necessarily per product across all categories. This means a product can be Amazon’s Choice for one search, but not for another related search.
To increase your chances of getting the Amazon’s Choice badge, focus on optimising your product listings through effective Amazon SEO, maintaining consistently high product quality and customer service, and ensuring your product is always in stock and ready for fast delivery.
While both the Amazon Buy Box and Amazon’s Choice are prestigious distinctions on the platform, they serve different purposes and are awarded according to different criteria. Understanding these differences can help you target your optimisation efforts more effectively.
The Buy Box focuses primarily on the seller’s performance and competitiveness for a specific product. Multiple sellers can offer the same product, and the Buy Box is awarded to the seller who, according to Amazon, provides the best combination of price, availability, and service. This is direct competition between sellers.
In contrast, Amazon’s Choice is a product-specific distinction, highlighting a particular product as the best option within a given search category. Here, different products (not different sellers of the same product) compete for the distinction. The criteria focus more on the product’s popularity, ratings, and how it performs in relation to the customer’s search intent.
Another key difference is that the Buy Box can switch quickly between eligible sellers based on real-time data, while Amazon’s Choice tends to be more stable and does not change as frequently. However, neither distinction is permanent – both can be lost if performance drops or competitive conditions change.
As a seller, it is advantageous to strive for both, as they complement each other. The Buy Box improves your conversion rate on product pages, while Amazon’s Choice increases your visibility and click-through rate in search results.
Winning the Buy Box is only half the battle – keeping it over time is the real challenge. With constantly shifting competitive conditions, maintaining Buy Box status requires strategic planning and continuous monitoring. Here are some strategies to sustain your Buy Box position in the long term:
Implement a robust Amazon marketing system that continuously monitors your Buy Box share and notifies you when it drops below certain thresholds. This allows you to quickly identify issues and implement solutions before they significantly affect your sales.
Pricing dynamics are constantly changing on Amazon. Use price monitoring tools to keep an eye on competitors’ prices and adjust your strategy accordingly. However, remember that blindly undercutting prices is rarely a sustainable strategy – you need to find a balance between competitiveness and profitability.
Constantly maintain and improve your seller metrics. This includes:
Stock management is an often-overlooked aspect of Buy Box optimisation. Out-of-stock situations can significantly harm your Buy Box eligibility, even after your inventory is replenished. Implement a predictive inventory management system to ensure you never run out of popular products.
Finally, consider diversifying your product range. By offering a broad selection of products, you can spread risk and ensure your overall sales remain stable, even if you temporarily lose the Buy Box on some products.
Product reviews play a critical role in both winning the Buy Box and achieving Amazon’s Choice status. They directly influence customer perception of your product and signal to Amazon that you deliver quality products and good service. Here’s how you can optimise this important factor:
Start by focusing on product quality as the foundation for positive reviews. No marketing trick can compensate for a product that does not meet customer expectations. Make sure your product is reliable, well-designed, and solves the problem it claims to address.
Proactive customer communication can dramatically improve your review rate and quality. Consider implementing an automated email sequence that follows up with customers after their purchase to ensure they are satisfied and to encourage happy customers to leave a review.
When you receive negative reviews, it is essential to respond professionally and constructively. Reply publicly with a solution-oriented approach that shows potential customers you take feedback seriously. This can often turn a negative customer experience into a positive one and enhance your overall profile.
Avoid asking for positive reviews or offering incentives in exchange for reviews, as this is against Amazon’s guidelines and can result in serious consequences for your account. Instead, focus on delivering an exceptional customer experience that naturally inspires positive reviews.
Finally, consider enrolling in the Amazon Vine programme when launching new products. This official Amazon programme can help you get honest reviews from trusted reviewers, which can kick-start your review profile and increase your chances of winning both the Buy Box and Amazon’s Choice.
Delivery-related factors have a huge impact on your Buy Box chances. Amazon prioritises sellers who can deliver products quickly, reliably, and with minimal hassle for the customer. Here are some strategies to optimise your delivery model:
Consider using Amazon FBA as your primary fulfilment method. When Amazon handles your fulfilment, you automatically gain access to Prime delivery, which dramatically increases your Buy Box chances. Amazon naturally trusts its own fulfilment service more, giving FBA sellers a significant advantage.
If you prefer to use your own fulfilment model (FBM), aim to qualify for Seller Fulfilled Prime. This programme allows selected sellers to offer Prime benefits while still managing their own shipping. The requirements are strict, but the advantages for Buy Box allocation can be substantial.
Regardless of your fulfilment method, it’s important to prioritise rapid order processing. Amazon measures the time from order receipt to dispatch, and sellers with consistently fast processing are more likely to win the Buy Box.
Regionalising your inventory can also improve your delivery speeds. By holding products closer to your main customer groups, you can reduce delivery times and shipping costs, improving both customer satisfaction and your Buy Box competitiveness.
Finally, consider offering free shipping where financially viable. Products with free shipping win the Buy Box more often, as the total price (product + shipping) is typically more competitive, and customers generally prefer offers without extra costs.
For serious Amazon sellers, it’s not enough just to implement basic strategies – you need advanced monitoring systems to stay ahead of the competition. Here are some sophisticated approaches for tracking and optimising your Buy Box and Amazon’s Choice performance:
Invest in specialised Buy Box tracking software that can provide you with real-time data on your Buy Box share across your product catalogue. These tools can alert you when you lose the Buy Box and provide insight into the reasons, so you can react quickly. This is especially important for sellers with a large number of ASINs.
Implement A/B testing of your product listings to identify which factors most affect your Buy Box and Amazon’s Choice performance. Systematically test different price points, image variations, titles, and descriptions to find the optimal combination for each product category.
Analyse your competitors’ strategies using Amazon marketing tools. Understand their pricing dynamics, inventory rotation, and review velocity. This competitor analysis can reveal opportunities to differentiate your offerings and gain a competitive advantage.
Develop a dashboard solution that integrates data from several sources – your seller account, third-party tools, and market analysis – to give a holistic view of your Amazon business. This can help you identify correlations between different factors and your Buy Box performance.
Finally, consider implementing automated repricing strategies based on predefined rules. These systems can dynamically adjust your prices based on competitors’ actions, stock levels, and other factors, ensuring you remain competitive without sacrificing too much profit.
Many sellers overlook the connection between their Amazon advertising strategy and their Buy Box and Amazon’s Choice performance. These elements are closely linked and can reinforce each other when implemented strategically. Here’s how:
Sponsored Products ads can increase your product visibility and sales volume, which indirectly improves your chances of achieving Amazon’s Choice status. Higher sales volume is a key signal to Amazon that your product is popular and valuable to customers, which is a core criterion for the badge.
When you advertise a product for which you currently have the Buy Box, you maximise the efficiency of your ad spend. The combination of premium placement in search results (via ads) and a higher conversion rate (via the Buy Box) creates a powerful synergy that can accelerate your sales growth.
Use targeted advertising to boost underperforming products that are close to achieving Amazon’s Choice status. By strategically increasing the exposure and sales of these products through ads, you may be able to push them over the threshold to earn the badge.
Sponsored Brands and Sponsored Display ads can also strengthen your brand’s visibility and authority, which can influence customer perception and indirectly improve your conversion rates. Higher conversion rates are a positive signal to Amazon’s algorithms that determine both the Buy Box and Amazon’s Choice.
Remember, however, that advertising spend affects your overall profitability, which can indirectly impact your ability to remain price competitive. Balance your ad investments carefully and constantly measure your ROI to ensure your strategy is sustainable in the long run.
Even experienced Amazon sellers often make mistakes that harm their Buy Box chances. By being aware of these pitfalls, you can avoid them and improve your position. Here are five of the most common errors:
Overly aggressive pricing can actually harm your Buy Box chances. Many sellers mistakenly believe that the lowest price automatically wins the Buy Box, but this is not the case. Amazon balances price with other factors, and extreme underpricing can signal potential issues with product quality or authenticity. Instead, focus on being competitive while maintaining healthy margins.
Poor inventory management is another critical mistake. Frequent out-of-stock situations not only hurt your immediate sales, but also impact your long-term Buy Box eligibility. Amazon favours sellers who can consistently meet demand. Implement a robust stock management system with automatic replenishment alerts to avoid this trap.
Ignoring seller metrics is a serious error. Many sellers focus so intensely on price and sales volume that they overlook the core performance metrics critical to Buy Box allocation. Regularly check your Account Health section in Seller Central and prioritise improving any metrics that do not meet Amazon’s standards.
Failing to optimise product listings not only reduces your visibility in search results, but can also affect your Buy Box performance. Incomplete or low-quality product descriptions, images, and attributes can lead to higher returns and lower customer satisfaction, which indirectly harms your Buy Box eligibility.
Finally, not adapting to seasonal changes is an overlooked mistake. Buy Box competition intensifies dramatically during holidays and special events. Sellers who do not adjust their strategies to accommodate these seasonal fluctuations risk losing valuable Buy Box time precisely when sales volumes are highest.
With limited resources, it is essential to prioritise which products you focus your Buy Box optimisation efforts on. Not all products have the same potential or value, and a strategic approach can maximise your return. Here’s how you can select the right products:
Start by analysing your products’ profit potential. Buy Box optimisation often requires price competition, so focus on products with healthy margins that can absorb minor price adjustments without becoming unprofitable. Products with extremely low margins rarely deliver a good return on your optimisation efforts.
Assess the competition level for each product. Some ASINs have such intense competition that it takes disproportionately many resources to win the Buy Box consistently. Others may have moderate competition, where targeted optimisations can yield significant results. Use tools to analyse how many active sellers are competing for each product.
Examine seasonal patterns in your product categories. Prioritise Buy Box optimisation for products approaching their high season, when sales potential is greatest. For seasonal products, timing is crucial – it is often more valuable to hold the Buy Box for 80% of the high season than 20% of the whole year.
Evaluate your current Buy Box percentage for each product. Products where you already hold a moderate Buy Box share (e.g. 30-60%) often represent the best optimisation opportunities. These are within reach with targeted improvements, while products with very low Buy Box share may require more drastic changes.
Finally, consider the strategic value of products for your business. Flagship products that define your brand, or products that lead to valuable repeat purchases, may deserve special attention – even if their immediate ROI is not the highest.
Buy Box optimisation can be complex and time-consuming, especially for sellers with large product catalogues or limited internal resources. Fortunately, there are various support options to help you navigate this challenge:
Professional Amazon consultants with specific expertise in Buy Box optimisation can provide tailored advice based on your unique situation. These experts stay up to date with Amazon’s constantly evolving algorithms and can identify opportunities and issues you may not have noticed yourself.
Amazon agencies like WeMarket offer comprehensive services that address all aspects of your Amazon presence, including Buy Box optimisation. This can be especially valuable if you need help with multiple facets of your Amazon business at once, as Buy Box performance is closely linked to other elements such as listing optimisation, pricing strategies, and advertising campaigns.
Software tools dedicated to Buy Box optimisation can automate many aspects of the process, from monitoring to price adjustments. These tools can save significant time and provide data-driven insights to inform your strategy.
Amazon courses and workshops can be a cost-effective way to build internal expertise. With the right Amazon course, you or your team members can acquire the skills needed to implement and maintain effective Buy Box strategies.
Peer networks and Amazon seller forums can provide valuable information based on other sellers’ experiences. While advice from these sources should be carefully evaluated, they can often offer insights into real-time changes and strategies that work in specific niches.
Buy Box and Amazon’s Choice represent two of the most powerful factors that can drive your success on the Amazon platform. They are not just badges or placements – they are fundamental drivers of visibility, trust, and conversion that directly impact your bottom line.
To maximise your success on Amazon, you should integrate Buy Box and Amazon’s Choice optimisation as central pillars of your overall strategy. This involves a holistic approach that addresses all the factors we have discussed: from price competition and seller metrics to inventory management and customer service quality.
Remember, consistency is key. Buy Box and Amazon’s Choice are not one-time achievements but dynamic statuses that require ongoing attention and adaptation. Market and competitive conditions are constantly changing, and your strategy must evolve accordingly.
By implementing the strategies and avoiding the pitfalls discussed in this article, you can significantly improve your chances of winning and maintaining both Buy Box and Amazon’s Choice status. This will not only increase your sales in the short term, but also build a stronger, more sustainable Amazon business in the long run.
Whether you are new to Amazon or an experienced seller, optimising for the Buy Box and working towards Amazon’s Choice is not optional but essential elements of a successful Amazon strategy. Start implementing these principles today and watch your Amazon business grow in the coming months.
At WeMarket, we offer businesses a benchmark report that compares their marketing efforts with their key competitors. You decide which competitors we should compare against.
We specialise in selling physical goods online and growing webshops – and now you can benefit from this expertise, even if you’re not already a client.
It’s completely free.
